📺 What to Watch Tonight: September 23, 2025 — Alien Finales, Murder Returns, and a Million-Dollar Talent Showdown

Welcome to your daily dose of TV drama, sparkle, and chaos — lovingly curated by The TV Cave, your one-stop binge bunker for everything worth watching (and side-eyeing) on the small screen. Whether you're in the mood for high-stakes politics in a sleepy town or celebs clinging to the last notes of their one-hit wonders, tonight’s lineup is giving “something for everyone.”

So grab the remote and let's dive in 👇

🕒 EARLY BIRD BINGERS: 3:00 AM ET Drops for the Night Owls & Stream Team What to Watch

💣 Bodyguard of Lies — Paramount+

Secrets, scandals, and four U.S. administrations worth of denial? This explosive doc peels back the sanitized layers of the Afghanistan War. It's less "history lesson," more "truth bomb." Definitely not light viewing — but very necessary.

🎤 Cristela Alonzo: Upper Classy — Netflix

Cristela is back with laughs, life lessons, and a little shade on adulthood. If you’ve ever fake-smiled while checking your auto-pay account, this one’s for you.

🕵️‍♀️ Only Murders in the Building — Hulu

Mabel and Oliver dig deep (again) and get help from…the support staff? Meanwhile, Charles plays dinner detective. Still funny, still clever, and yes, we’re also obsessed with the talking robot doorman.

🕗 PRIME TIME POPCORN: 8:00 PM ET

👽 Alien: Earth (Season 1 Finale) — FX

Big twists. Bigger stakes. Will humanity survive the new power shift? Or will it go the way of cable news integrity? Not yet renewed, so this finale might double as a goodbye kiss. 👋

⚾ Clemente — History Channel

More than a baseball legend, Roberto Clemente was a cultural icon and humanitarian force. This moving doc knocks it out of the park emotionally.

💃 Dancing With the Stars — ABC

It’s One-Hit Wonder night! Which means we’re getting "Macarena" footwork and way too many "Who Let the Dogs Out"

references. All 14 couples are giving it their nostalgic best.

🕵️‍♂️ Murder in a Small Town (Season 2 Premiere) — Fox

Cassandra wins big, but Mayor Holman isn’t here for it. With political sabotage and drama hotter than a Southern summer, this sleepy town is waking up to some serious heat.

💎 The Real Housewives of Salt Lake City — Bravo

Lisa’s dropping legal tea, Heather’s playing peacemaker (reluctantly), and Mary’s in her "supportive mom" era. Pass the popcorn and the prenups.

🎤 The Voice — NBC

Blind Auditions roll on as Michael Bublé, Niall Horan, Reba, and Snoop turn chairs and charm contestants. Someone give Snoop his own lounge act already.

🕘 STAGE LIGHTS & SHOCKERS: 9:00 PM ET

🎪 America’s Got Talent (Season 20 Finale) — NBC

Ten finalists. One million dollars. And the kind of weird, wonderful acts you only see on AGT. From high school choirs to glow-in-the-dark dancers, this is the ultimate talent showdown.

🏥 The Devil Is Busy — HBO

This gritty documentary short gives you a raw look inside a women’s healthcare clinic in Atlanta. Honest, urgent, and essential.

🫀 Doc (Encore of Season 2 Premiere) — Fox

In case you missed it: a father makes the ultimate sacrifice in a heartwrenching case. Catch up before Episode 2 hits next week. (Because feelings.)

📰 The Lowdown (Series Premiere) — FX

Ethan Hawke is out here playing a truth-obsessed “truthstorian” (no, seriously). If you love citizen journalism with a side of chaos, this two-episode debut is your jam.

🕙 LATE NIGHT CRIMINAL MINDS: 10:00 PM ET

🧠 High Potential — ABC

Cold cases, hot leads, and a Game Maker pulling strings behind the scenes? Morgan is on the case — and we’re 100% convinced this show is about to become your new procedural obsession.

🔥 TL;DR — What You Can’t Miss Tonight:

• For drama lovers: Murder in a Small Town brings political games and small-town secrets.

• For nostalgia heads: Dancing With the Stars hits the one-hit goldmine.

• For docu-junkies: Clemente and Bodyguard of Lies will give your brain a workout.

• For talent show fans: America’s Got Talent could change someone’s life tonight — no big deal.

• For chaos gremlins: The Real Housewives never disappoint.

🛋️ That’s Your TV Cave Guide for September 23!

Set your DVRs, fire up those streaming queues, and prepare to talk TV at the water cooler (or group chat) like a pro. And remember — we watch so you don't have to...unless it's messy. Then we definitely watch.

👉 Be sure to follow The TV Cave for daily guides, snappy recaps, and unfiltered takes on everything hitting your screen.