The Bear Season 5 Episode 4 Review: Richie Finally Says What Everyone Needed to Hear

As the final season of FX’s critically acclaimed restaurant dramedy, The Bear, reaches its midpoint, the ongoing narrative continues to carry the weight of goodbye without ever fully saying the word. “Ribs,” the fourth installment of Season 5, does not rush toward the end. It lingers once again on the same day, in the rain and in between the uneasy silence of what still hangs in the air for Chef Carmy Berzatto, played by Jeremy Allen White, and his crew.

The episode opens outside, under a tarp, with Richie (Ebon Moss-Bachrach) trying to shape a motivational speech while the relentless rain turns Chicago gray and unforgiving. Carmy joins him for a smoke, still wrestling with his decision to leave the restaurant. Richie’s response is blunt -- Carmy should quit if that is what he needs to do, but he should also feel bad about it. No sugar-coating here. Just the kind of tough-love honesty that can only come from someone who is working through their own pain.

From there, the episode begins to quietly press against the lump in your throat. Carmy admits that being put on prep duty by Chef Sydney (Ayo Edebiri), cutting onions of all things, has pulled him back to the beginning—before his ambition and reputation, before his grief and genius became so tightly intertwined. He misses the simplicity of having a task and finishing it. Richie sees the danger in such a retreat. Carmy may be brilliant in isolation, but that brilliance has never made the “differently abled” chef a good teammate. Perhaps the work Carmy needs most is not found in his culinary skills. Maybe he needs to learn how to think about other people. Ouch!

For once, Carmy taps into his self-awareness when he asks Richie how he is doing. Surprisingly, Richie does not hide behind a joke or a fight. He is not okay. Earlier that morning, he got into a car accident because he was thinking about Mikey, Carmy’s deceased older brother, played in flashbacks by Jon Bernthal, and an old version of himself he still cannot outrun. The scene is small, but it sets the emotional tone for the episode’s 39 minutes.

Back inside the restaurant, the building is still betraying the crew. Teddy has fallen through the ceiling (a pile-on problem that came at the close of Episode 3); the contractor is not coming until the next day; and the kitchen is caught somewhere between disaster response and dinner service. Nevertheless, Chef Syd cannot afford to indulge the chaos. They are overbooked on reservations with too little food, too few plates, too few hands, and not enough dry surfaces to make any of it work.

If Carmy’s assignment is to become human again, he starts awkwardly, but sincerely. He checks in on his sister Natalie (Abby Elliott), who is trying to hold the restaurant’s finances together while listening through a baby monitor as Donna (Jamie Lee Curtis) watches her child. The tenderness between Carmy and “Sugar” is one of the episode’s quiet gifts. The siblings spar over who had it worse growing up with their chaotic mother, then land on the truth neither wants to say too loudly — Mikey was truly her favorite. It is funny until it is not. That is The Bear at its best, isn’t it — letting subtle humor expose the characters’ open wounds instead of covering them.

Across town, Uncle Jimmy (Oliver Platt) is tangled in city bureaucracy, trying to understand air rights and the future of the building – believe me, it makes more sense in real time. Chef Syd is finding her voice because she has no other choice, moving from kitchen to makeshift dish pit — in a locker room, mind you — asking people what they need. Tina (Liza Colón-Zayas) insists she is fine, though her face tells the fuller story. Marcus (Lionel Boyce) absorbs Carmy’s decision with guarded calm. Neil (Matty Matheson) hides in the bathroom, hurt by the thought that Carmy’s leaving may change the shape of their friendship.

And through it all, the rain keeps falling. Which each episode, it is obvious the weather is simply the metaphor for the flood of emotions they are all trying avoid with Carmy’s impending departure. The end IS near, but the staff are just too exhausted from their more pressing issues to shed their respective tears over that fact. This season, the low-pressure system is hovering on the inside, marked by the scenes’ visual language of darkness, muted grays, and melancholy. With faces half-lit on screen, rooms warmed only by the golden glow of lamps and streetlights, every frame carries the feeling that something beloved is slipping away.

But, truly, the emotional center of “Ribs” comes at the pre-service family meal. Everyone gathers around one table, backlit by the glow from the streetlights. In the dimness, Chef Syd receives praise for the food, then makes sure Tina shares it, too. The words are few. The crew simply sits together and eats—quietly, in the dark. Because we know how far these people have come from the chaos of the sandwich shop to this fragile idea of family, the scene lands like a modern-day Last Supper.

Carmy’s best moment comes not in his need to control, but in his contribution when it matters. Passing through the kitchen, he tastes what is being prepared and sees a way to stretch the menu, to make the night’s signature dish work for a dining room that may not have enough to serve. He brings the idea to Sydney, his one-time protégé, but this time Carmy looks to her.

He waits for HER validation. When Sydney affirms it as the second-best dish she has ever had, the compliment carries years of history. The first, she reminds him, was the meal that led her to him. IYKYK.

Richie’s speech, when it finally comes, begins as something rehearsed and almost lost. The room is not with him, obvious in the hollowed-out eyes and faraway looks of his co-workers. So, he lets go of the performance and speaks from a hole in his heart. He talks about wanting to make things perfect, about how badly he wants the restaurant to feel right again, and then he remembers the best restaurant he ever knew. It was Mikey’s house — a place where you were wanted; a place where you were welcomed; a place where no one kicked you out.

With that, Richie drops the pep talk and gives his teammates their “why” to carry on. Suddenly, the episode shifts. Everything sharpens. The energy grows. Sydney and Natalie lay out the plan for what could very well be the restaurant’s final night, set to a pulse of synthesized electronic music; and just like that, the show returns to the rhythm that made it electric from the start — scenes moving with purpose, orders forming, hands working, every second counting. For the first time this season, we see not just a kitchen getting ready for service, but a family deciding, one more time, to show up for each other.

Then, in the final minutes, the alert of an ordinary reservation change shifts the atmosphere one last time. The possibility of a Michelin reviewer being in the house sends a charge through the room, flashing in our favorite chefs’ eyes. And after all the rain, all the doubt, all the ceiling caves and almost-collapses, The Bear — both the series and its namesake restaurant — stands at the edge of something defining.

“Ribs” is not loud in the way some of the series’ most memorable episodes have been. Its power is quieter, sadder, and maybe more lasting. It is about the cost of leaving, the burden of staying, and the grace of being asked, even once, how you are doing. It reminds us that The Bear has never really been about food. It has been about grief packaged as ambition, love disguised as labor, and the stubborn hope that a broken place can still feed the people inside it.

When the fade to black comes, the team is ready. Maybe not yet healed. Maybe not even environmentally safe. But ready, nonetheless. And after an episode this layered, meaningful, and beautifully restrained, the real question is, are we?!

Officially now halfway through its fifth and final season, only four more episodes remain of FX Productions’ The Bear. Catch each remaining episode on Thursdays until August 6. Stream the previous four seasons on Hulu now.

What did you think?

Change Image

• Loved it
• Hated it
• So/So