Star Trek: Strange New Worlds Season 4 Episode 2 Recap: Welcome Aboard the USS Griffin... If You Dare

Well...who at Star Trek: Strange New Worlds decided it was time to make a horror movie? Because, "The Griffin Effect Incident" had us looking over our shoulders more than once. What starts off as a classic Starfleet mission quickly transforms into a psychological nightmare that proves sometimes the scariest thing in space isn't a Klingon or a Gorn—it's your own mind.

Before the episode even gets rolling, longtime Trekkies get a fun little treat. The updated opening sequence includes the USS Athena from Starfleet Academy, a subtle nod to Star Trek's upcoming 60th anniversary celebration. It's a blink-and-you'll-miss-it moment, but it's exactly the kind of fan service that earns a smile before the real nightmare begins.

This week's mission belongs to James T. Kirk, Spock and La'an, who stumble across the long-missing USS Griffin after detecting an old Federation distress signal. The ship vanished nine years ago with roughly 300 people aboard, so naturally everyone's first question is, "Where did they all go?" Spoiler alert: this episode isn't in any hurry to answer that question, and honestly, that's part of the fun.

The second the trio beams aboard the Griffin, every instinct is screaming, "Turn around!" The ship is dark, eerily quiet and somehow still has gravity even though it absolutely shouldn't. Then Kirk starts hearing a baby crying that no one else can hear. Girl...absolutely not. If Starfleet offered hazard pay, this would've been the episode to cash that check.

One thing Strange New Worlds absolutely nails here is the atmosphere. The Griffin doesn't rely on monsters jumping out of every corner. Instead, it lets the silence do the heavy lifting. Empty corridors, abandoned belongings and flickering lights create this constant feeling that someone—or something—is watching. Every time a door opens, you're bracing yourself for the worst, and somehow the episode keeps finding new ways to crank up the tension.

Then the hallucinations begin. Without giving away every twist, the mysterious force aboard the Griffin starts preying on each character's deepest fears and regrets. Kirk's visions involving his son David hit especially hard because they remind us there's still a very human side to the future captain of the Enterprise. We've watched him flirt, crack jokes and confidently take charge, but this hour lets Paul Wesley show a much more vulnerable version of Kirk, and it works.

Can we talk about Paul Wesley for a second? Because every appearance he makes, he feels more comfortable in this role. At first there were plenty of comparisons to William Shatner—and there always will be—but Wesley has stopped trying to imitate anyone. He's creating his own version of Kirk, and episodes like this show exactly why that's the right call. Not us getting emotional over James T. Kirk...

Meanwhile, Spock gets his own emotional gut punch when T'Pring suddenly appears aboard the Griffin. Is she really there? Is she another hallucination? Is the ship just trying to mess with him? Watching Spock desperately cling to logic while everything around him refuses to make sense creates some of Ethan Peck's strongest material of the season. Poor Spock can't even have a haunted ship experience without it becoming emotionally complicated.

And then there's La'an. Christina Chong continues proving week after week why La'an has become one of the franchise's best newer characters. She walks into danger without hesitation, keeps everyone focused when panic starts creeping in and still manages to show just enough vulnerability to remind us she's carrying plenty of emotional baggage herself. Her chemistry with both Spock and Kirk remains one of the show's secret weapons, making this trio incredibly easy to root for.

The mystery surrounding the Griffin is what keeps everything moving. Every new discovery raises another question. Why are there no bodies? What happened to the crew? Why was part of sickbay barricaded? Who—or what—is really haunting the ship? Instead of handing viewers easy answers, the episode keeps peeling back layers until reality itself becomes questionable. By that point, you're just along for the ride, trying to figure out what's real alongside the crew.

Captain Pike and the Enterprise eventually arrive to help, but if you think that means everyone's safe...bless your heart. Whatever is lurking aboard the Griffin doesn't exactly care who's wearing the captain's chair. Even the rescue mission starts feeling less like a rescue and more like another trap waiting to spring.

And can we talk about that ending? Because just when it seems like the crew has escaped the nightmare, Strange New Worlds throws in one final image that's guaranteed to have fans theorizing all week. Not us staring at the screen wondering if the Griffin is actually finished with everyone. That's all we'll say because this twist deserves to be experienced without spoilers.

What makes "The Griffin Effect Incident" work isn't just the scares. It's the confidence to let Star Trek experiment. The franchise has always played with different genres, but leaning this hard into psychological horror could've easily felt gimmicky. Instead, it feels fresh, unsettling and surprisingly emotional. The creepy moments land, the mystery keeps you hooked and the character work gives the entire episode real weight.

Simply put, this is one of Strange New Worlds' strongest episodes to date. It balances suspense, mystery, humor and heart while reminding us that exploring the unknown doesn't always lead to strange new civilizations. Sometimes it leads to a haunted starship that's better left drifting through space.

We'll definitely be sleeping with a light on after this one.

Rating: 4.7 out of 5 stars.

What did you think?

Change Image

• Loved it
• Hated it
• So/So