All Her Fault Episode 3 Recap: Ana’s Confession and a Chilling New Suspect

Ana shows up at Marissa and Peter’s doorstep looking shaken, guilty, and ready to confess. She apologizes for lying and finally admits that yes—she does know Carrie Finch. Not only that, but she had actually told Carrie personal details about Marissa and Peter: what they did for work, the kind of home they lived in… all the little things you’d normally never think twice about sharing, but that suddenly feel chilling in hindsight.

The police sit Ana down as well, and she tells them about a day in the city when Peter was running a race. Carrie had met up with them, but things took a sharp turn when Carrie got into what looked like tense interaction with a man. Ana witnesses this from a distance and didn’t see the man’s face but she knew that the interaction felt off.

Back at the search site, Colin is taking charge, organizing a coordinated effort through the neighborhood. Esther—the woman whose house Marissa mistakenly burst into while desperately searching for Milo—comes out to help too. Despite the awkward introduction, she jumps in wholeheartedly, showing just how invested the whole neighborhood has become.

But while Colin is helping lead the search on the outside, behind the scenes he’s juggling something far darker. He calls his assistant and instructs her to pull money from one trust fund to patch the debt of another. And not just any account—he tells her to take the money from Lia’s trust fund. It’s an alarming glimpse into how comfortable he is shifting money around, even when it’s morally murky.

Meanwhile, the police run a digital sweep from all the nearby cameras, trying to pull up the mystery man Ana saw arguing with Carrie. After combing through footage and running system matches, they finally see the man’s face. 

We see Ester come home and walk by a picture of herself with a young man – the same guy that we now know was arguing with Carrie at the race. The web around Milo’s disappearance tightens—and the connections are getting more personal than anyone expected.

What did you think?

Change Image

• Loved it
• Hated it
• So/So