📺 What to Watch Tonight: September 4, 2025 - The Paper & Star Trek

Welcome to The TV Cave’s Daily Watchlist – your go-to spot for figuring out what’s actually worth watching (and what to skip like expired leftovers). From primetime drama bombs to juicy reality TV meltdowns, here’s your guide to what’s hot and happening on September 4, 2025.

🌙 Late-Night Drops Worth Losing Sleep Over

🔥 BET+ | All the Queen's Men – Season 4 Finale (3:00 AM ET)

Plot twist level: Chef’s kiss. Verdict’s in, and Madam is in deep, deadly drama. She's now a marked woman, along with Midnight (seriously, someone give this man a break). The stakes are lethal, and the renewal status? Still TBD. BET, don’t play with us.

👻 Hulu | Blood & Myth – Documentary Premiere (3:00 AM ET)

True crime meets the X-Files.A sleepy Alaskan village gets rocked by violence, and one man thinks there’s more to the bloodshed than just bad luck. Paranormal chaos ensues. If you love spooky docu-series with a side of WTF, this one’s calling.

🕵️‍♂️ BritBox | Lynley – Series Premiere (3:00 AM ET)

Aristocrat + badass cop = murder-solving chaos. A posh detective (Leo Suter, bringing serious smolder) teams up with a street-smart sergeant (Sofia Barclay) in a classic “opposites clash” crime drama. Think Bridgerton meets Broadchurch. British TV lovers, you’re welcome.

🔫 Paramount+ | NCIS: Tony & Ziva – First 3 Episodes (3:00 AM ET)

THE fan-fave couple is BACK (and running for their lives). Ziva and Tony reunite (finally) when his security firm is attacked. Cue a European cat-and-mouse chase, emotional trauma, and that sweet sweet slow-burn chemistry. Grab snacks, you’ll want to binge.

📰 Peacock | The Paper – Full Season Drop (3:00 AM ET)

From the people who brought you The Office — kinda. The original documentary crew stumbles into a struggling Midwest newspaper and its hot mess of a publisher. Sharp, funny, and already renewed. Think The Office meets The Newsroom with a Midwest twist.

🚀 Paramount+ | Star Trek: Strange New Worlds (New Episode – 3:00 AM ET)

Ortegas: Crash-landed, isolated, and existential.

Toxic moons and inner demons? Standard Star Trek Thursday. Ortegas is stuck and questioning everything. Sci-fi drama with a side of soul-searching? Engage.

📣 Prime Time Picks – Where the Drama Lives

🏠 CBS | Big Brother (8:00 PM ET)

It’s eviction night, baby. Another houseguest gets the boot and we’re here for the meltdowns, manipulations, and diary room shade. Floaters, grab a life vest.

🍊 Bravo | The Real Housewives of Orange County (8:00 PM ET)

Set-ups, medical scares, and parenting fails – just another OC night. Katie swears she was framed, Gina gets raw about Matt’s heart attack, and Emily and Shane can’t agree on anything except how not to co-parent. A mess? Yes. But the delicious kind.

🏈 NBC | Sunday Night Football on a Thursday? (8:20 PM ET)

Special Night: Cowboys vs. Eagles The NFL’s jumping the schedule with this juicy NFC East grudge match. It’s drama, testosterone, and touchdowns — aka, reality TV for sports fans.

🔥 Late-Night Heat – After Dark Favorites

⚽ FXX | Necaxa (9:00 PM ET)

Sports docu-drama gets real. Veteran Diego de Buen is channeling retro vibes to pump up the squad after a brutal loss, while Eva turns a padel match into a full-on showdown. This one’s got grit and goals.

🦸‍♂️ HBO Max | Peacemaker (9:00 PM ET)

Peacemaker: Hero or hot mess (or both)? He’s basking in public praise but using an alternate dimension to fix his love life? Sure. Meanwhile, Economos is getting dragged for the mission fail. This show remains unhinged in the best way.

🛳️ Bravo | The Real Housewives of Miami (9:00 PM ET)

Luxury cruise? Check. Emotional baggage? Also check. Lisa is pressuring Jody for a ring, Kiki unpacks decades of daddy issues, and Marysol tries to play nice hostess... which goes exactly as well as you’d expect.

👗 Fashionably Late: Runway Realness

🧵 Freeform | Project Runway (10:00 PM ET)

Yee-haw couture is the vibe. The designers are told to wrangle up a Western chic fit — expect fringe, drama, and someone inevitably hot-gluing denim in a panic. Timeless fashion advice: Don’t anger the sewing machine gods.

🕳️ Final Thoughts from the Cave

Today’s lineup is packed tighter than a Housewives Botox party. Whether you're bingeing espionage in Europe (Tony & Ziva), riding fashion rodeos (Project Runway), or diving head-first into paranormal cold cases (Blood & Myth), September 4 has something for every kind of TV junkie.

So grab that remote, cancel your plans, and don’t forget: in the war of scripted vs. reality, we watch it all so you don’t have to — only at The TV Cave.

Need tomorrow’s guide? Follow us daily and never miss the must-watch madness again.