'Wednesday' Season 2 Part 1 Review: Still Goth, Still Weird, Still Totally Addictive

Okay, so Wednesday is back on Netflix with Season 2 Part 1, and honestly, it’s exactly the creepy, quirky ride we signed up for—mostly. Jenna Ortega returns as the ultimate deadpan queen, and while the story sometimes feels like it’s juggling one too many creepy plot threads, it still delivers enough dark fun to keep you bingeing. Here’s my take on what’s working, what’s dragging, and why you should definitely give it a shot (even if you have zero patience for slow burns).

Back to Nevermore and All Its Strange Glory

If you loved the first season’s spooky school vibes and weird family drama, you’ll feel right at home. Wednesday Addams is back, and she’s got a new problem—a stalker who’s creepier than your average obsessed fan, plus a murder mystery involving murder crows because, yes, that’s a thing now. Add in the looming threat of the LOIS program (which stands for Long-term Outcast Integration Study, because acronyms are scary too), and you’ve got yourself a stew of secrets and suspicions.

Jenna Ortega absolutely owns this role. Her sarcastic, deadpan delivery is flawless, and she somehow manages to make Wednesday’s morbid obsessions both hilarious and strangely relatable. I swear, every time she rolls her eyes or gives that “I’m done with humanity” look, I’m right there with her.

Creepy Conspiracies and a Side of Slow Burn

Here’s the deal—this part of the season takes its sweet time setting things up. The first couple of episodes felt like they were dragging a bit. Like, come on already, let’s get to the creepy chase or the bonfire chaos! But by episode three, things pick up, and the tension starts to simmer nicely. The stalker Agnes DeMille? Definitely a character who keeps you on edge, even if the pacing gets a little sluggish before she fully creeps in.

Plot-wise, there’s a lot happening—visions of Enid’s death, dark family secrets, school rituals, and that whole murder crow mystery. Sometimes it feels like the show is trying to do too much at once, which can get a little confusing if you’re not paying full attention. But hey, it’s a gothic soap opera with supernatural twists, so some chaos is kind of the point.

New Faces and Familiar Faves

One of the highlights for me was seeing Steve Buscemi as Principal Dort—his quirky, offbeat presence is perfect for this strange little world. Thandiwe Newton as Dr. Fairburn also adds some serious intrigue. And of course, Morticia and Gomez Addams showing up to remind us why this family is the ultimate dark dynasty is always a treat.

That said, not every character hits the mark. Pugsley and Eugene kind of felt like they wandered onto the set and forgot what they were supposed to do. Some storylines felt tossed in just to fill space, which is a bummer because I want more of the weird, lovable gang, not less.

Visuals That Slay Every Time

If you watch Wednesday for the style and atmosphere, you are in for a treat. The show’s goth aesthetic is stronger than ever. Moody hallways, eerie rituals, and costumes that scream “I woke up like this, but make it spooky.” Tim Burton’s signature vibe is dripping off every scene, making it one of those shows you want to pause just to admire the set design.

The Verdict: Worth Your Time, But Patience Is Required

Look, if you want a fast-paced mystery with all questions answered by episode three, this might not be your jam. The pacing drags a bit, and the tangled plot threads can make your brain hurt. But if you’re here for the mood, the witty deadpan humor, and watching Jenna Ortega slay every line, Wednesday Season 2 Part 1 is still a win.

It’s creepy, it’s kooky, and it knows exactly how weird it wants to be. And honestly, that’s why I keep coming back.

So, what did you think? Did you get sucked into the stalking, crows, and all the goth glam? Or did you get lost in the story maze? Drop your thoughts and let’s fangirl or fanboy about Wednesday’s wild world together!

What did you think?

Change Image

• Loved it
• Hated it
• So/So