Eternally Yours Season 1 Episode 2 Recap: Max's Vampire Life Gets Complicated
Spoilers ahead for Eternally Yours Season 1, Episode 2, “Baby Vampire.”
Well, look at that. Sometimes sticking with a show actually pays off! After a pilot that didn't completely win me over, Eternally Yours returned with its second episode, “Baby Vampire,” and I enjoyed this one considerably more. The comedy felt more natural, the supernatural world got a little bigger, and the characters finally had something more interesting to do than explain their very unusual family situation. And apparently, becoming a vampire doesn't excuse you from giving a presentation at work. Who knew?
Being Dead Is Apparently Not a Good Enough Excuse to Miss Work
Picking up after the pilot's rather unfortunate incident involving Max (Jaren Lewison), a marble bust, and an unexpected introduction to immortality, Episode 2 finds Max waking up to some life-changing news. Emma (Helen J. Shen) informs her boyfriend that he's now a vampire, but Max isn't buying it. To be fair, imagine going to your girlfriend's house, discovering her entire family drinks blood, nearly dying, and waking up to learn you've joined the club. That's a lot to process before breakfast.
Charles (Ed Weeks), who wasn't exactly Max's biggest fan when he was human, isn't thrilled about having another vampire around. He makes it clear that Max cannot leave the house until they know he can control his new abilities. It's a reasonable concern considering Max doesn't even believe he's a vampire yet.
Unfortunately, Max has responsibilities. His coworker Benji calls because there's an important presentation happening at their Social Security office, and Max is apparently determined not to miss it. Now, I've never worked at the Social Security Administration, but I genuinely had no idea they were doing this many presentations. What exactly are we presenting? The latest retirement statistics? A PowerPoint on why nobody can ever get through on the phone?
Whatever it is, Max considers it important enough to ignore a house full of centuries-old vampires. He manages to trick Jesse (Parker Young), who has been tasked with keeping an eye on him, and heads off to work. Naturally, this is a terrible idea, but what would a vampire sitcom be without someone ignoring perfectly reasonable warnings?
Max's First Day as a Vampire Goes About as Well as Expected
Max makes it to the office, but his newfound vampire abilities decide this is the perfect time to introduce themselves. His heightened senses and other powers begin emerging during his presentation, making an already awkward situation considerably worse. Watching Max desperately try to maintain some sense of normalcy while his body is doing things he cannot explain was one of the episode's funniest developments.
The man is trying to get through a workday while experiencing an entirely different kind of employee transformation. Things take a dangerous turn when his growing thirst for blood nearly leads him to bite Benji. Thankfully, Charles arrives before Max can make his coworker the first victim of his new dietary requirements.
One of the funnier complications during the rescue is the vampire rule about needing an invitation to enter a building. Emma, Liz, and Jesse try getting inside Max's workplace and it isn't quite as easy as simply walking through the front door. It's little details like this that make the show more entertaining. The writers are beginning to explore what happens when traditional vampire rules collide with everyday modern life and there's plenty of comedy to be found there.
Charles Needs a Friend, Preferably One Who Actually Likes Him
While Max is busy being a potential workplace hazard, Charles has a completely different problem. He wants a friend, which sounds simple enough until you remember who we're dealing with.
Throughout the episode, Charles attempts to build a friendship with his coworker Eric (Ken Kirby), who doesn't appear particularly interested in becoming his new best buddy. Considering Charles has spent centuries being difficult, watching him struggle with something as ordinary as making a friend is pretty amusing.
I actually enjoyed this storyline because it gives Charles something to do outside his ongoing disapproval of Max. There's something entertaining about an immortal vampire who can survive hundreds of years but can't quite navigate a workplace friendship. And for someone who is so quick to judge Max, Charles isn't exactly demonstrating outstanding social skills himself.
Still, when things go sideways at the Social Security office, Charles steps up and saves Max from making an enormous mistake. He may not particularly like the guy, but at least he's willing to prevent an unnecessary bloodbath. That's practically a bonding experience in this family.
Emma Makes Her Choice, and Charles Has to Deal With It
Back at the house, Charles has had enough. Max has already ignored instructions, endangered a human, and demonstrated that he's nowhere near ready to manage his new existence. Charles decides the best solution is to remove him from the coven, which I'm sure sounds perfectly reasonable to Charles and absolutely nobody else in the room.
Of course, there's one very important problem with that plan: Emma. Earlier in the episode, she expressed concerns about how quickly everything was moving between her and Max. They haven't exactly been together long enough to figure out their relationship, and now they're potentially facing eternity together.
Forget discussing whose apartment they'll live in or whether they're ready to meet each other's parents. These two have skipped several relationship milestones and gone straight to eternal commitment. That's quite a leap for a couple still
figuring things out.
But when Charles threatens to kick Max out, Emma makes her position clear. If Max leaves, she's leaving too, and just like that, Charles suddenly finds room for one more vampire. Funny how that works when your daughter calls your bluff.
It's a predictable resolution, but it works because Charles clearly doesn't want to lose Emma. He may have hundreds of years of experience, but he's learning that being an overbearing father still has consequences. Immortality apparently doesn't come with a parenting handbook.
Werewolves, Vampire Hunters, and a Bigger Supernatural World
What really caught my attention this week was learning that vampires aren't the only supernatural creatures in this universe. Apparently, werewolves exist, and so do vampire hunters! Now we're talking, because this is exactly the kind of development that makes me want to keep watching.
This is where Eternally Yours started to feel more promising to me. The pilot focused heavily on introducing Charles, Liz, Emma, and the rest of the family, but Episode 2 hints at a much larger world beyond their household.
Vampire hunters could create some genuinely entertaining problems for a family that's already struggling to keep its secrets. And werewolves? There are all sorts of directions the writers could take that revelation, especially if these creatures eventually find their way into the family's everyday lives.
The show doesn't need to become a supernatural action series, but having those possibilities available makes the premise much more interesting. There's only so much comedy you can squeeze out of Charles being irritated with his daughter's boyfriend before something else needs to happen.
And since Eternally Yours comes from Ghosts creators Joe Port and Joe Wiseman, I have one more request: Can we please get a Ghosts crossover at some point? I'm not saying it needs to happen tomorrow, but the comedic possibilities are sitting right there. A house full of ghosts meeting a family of vampires? Somebody make the phone calls, because I need to see how that conversation plays out.
Final Thoughts: Now I'm Interested
“Baby Vampire” was a definite improvement over the premiere for me. The humor landed better, Max's disastrous return to work gave the episode some much-needed chaos, and Charles trying to make a friend was an entertaining subplot. More importantly, the series finally gave me a reason to be curious about what comes next.
Introducing werewolves and vampire hunters opens the door to some potentially fun storytelling, while Max's transformation changes the dynamics within the family. There are still characters I want to get to know better, and I'm hoping the series continues finding ways to make its supernatural premise feel fresh.
After Episode 2, I'm considerably more optimistic about where things are heading. I'm glad I didn't give up after the pilot, because Eternally Yours might have more bite than I initially thought. And if we eventually get that Ghosts crossover? Even better.
Eternally Yours airs Thursdays on CBS, with episodes available to stream on Paramount+.
What did you think?
Loved it
Hated it
So/So
Comments