Criminal Minds Evolution Season 19 Premiere Recap: The Fan Has Arrived and the BAU Is Already in Trouble
- Je-Ree
- 12 hours ago
- 3 min read
The BAU is back, and somebody out there clearly missed Sicarius a little too much.
Criminal Minds: Evolution returned to Paramount+ on May 28 with a two-episode Season 19 premiere and the show wasted absolutely no time getting to the drama. The new season drops the team into fresh territory while keeping one very familiar face lurking in the background and introduces a brand new villain who might just be the most unsettling UnSub the series has ever cooked up.
Showrunner Erica Messer promised heading into Season 19 that the show would be hitting the reset button in the best possible way. A full year has passed since the events of the Season 18 finale and the BAU has had time to breathe. The premiere episode, titled "Now and Then," uses that time jump wisely. The team feels cool, calm and collected, which makes the moment everything starts unraveling again hit that much harder.
The premiere does not spend its runtime drowning in Season 18 mythology, which is a smart move. New viewers to the show can reasonably jump in here without needing a doctoral thesis on Elias Voit's entire backstory. That said, longtime fans get enough connective tissue to make the premiere feel like a worthy continuation rather than a soft reboot wearing a familiar face.
The central villain of Season 19 is a new UnSub the team calls The Fan, a copycat killer who has modeled himself entirely after Elias Voit. Precise, calculated, and deeply committed to his obsession, The Fan is not simply mimicking Sicarius for shock value. He is trying to surpass him, and that distinction makes every scene involving this character feel genuinely tense.
The premiere does an excellent job establishing The Fan as a credible threat without immediately overplaying his hand. The show gives viewers enough to understand exactly how dangerous this person is while still leaving room for the season to build. It is a difficult balance that the writers pull off cleanly in these opening two hours.
Zach Gilford continues to be one of the most compelling reasons to keep watching this show. In Season 19, Voit is attempting something resembling atonement, sitting down for a series of revealing interviews designed to help the BAU understand what made him Sicarius in the first place. It is an uncomfortable watch in the best possible way. Every time the camera sits on Gilford, you are waiting for the mask to slip, and that tension never fully releases.
His presence also raises a question the season seems very interested in exploring: can understanding a monster actually help you stop the next one? The premiere does not answer that question, but it plants the seed beautifully.
Joe Mantegna, A.J. Cook, Kirsten Vangsness, Aisha Tyler and the rest of the BAU ensemble step back into their roles as comfortably as an old pair of shoes. The chemistry that has always made this show watchable remains fully intact. Guest stars this season include Yvette Nicole Brown, Clark Gregg and Jeri Ryan, as the episodes roll out weekly toward the July 23 finale.
Criminal Minds: Evolution Season 19 is off to one of its strongest starts in years. The two-episode premiere is confident, propulsive television that respects both the franchise's history and the audience's intelligence. With The Fan shaping up to be a legitimately terrifying presence and Voit's arc adding layers the show has rarely attempted, Season 19 feels like a show that has rediscovered exactly what made it appointment viewing in the first place.
New episodes drop weekly on Paramount+. If you let this one sit on your watchlist, move it to the top.
What did you think of the Season 19 premiere? Drop your take in the comments below and tell us — is The Fan already scarier than Sicarius?
What did you think?
Loved it
Hated it
So/So