What to Watch: Thursday, September 18, 2025: Reasonable Doubt Returns

Welcome back to The TV Cave, where we shovel through the streaming piles and primetime madness to bring you exactly what’s worth watching today. Whether you're in the mood for drama, reality chaos, or a football showdown with shoulder pads and egos, we've got your watchlist locked and loaded.

Let’s get into it — today’s TV lineup is stacked.

🕒 Wake & Binge (3:00 AM ET Drop Zone)

If you're up before the sun or just skipping sleep altogether (relatable), here’s what’s new and shiny on streaming:

🍸 Netflix | Black Rabbit | Series Premiere

Jude Law is playing a NYC nightlife kingpin. Jason Bateman crashes in as his chaos magnet of a brother. Drama? Check. Secrets? Check. Slow-burn sibling dysfunction in a gritty neon-lit setting? Double check.🛋️ Eight episodes dropped, so you

🕵️‍♂️ Paramount+ | NCIS: Tony & Ziva

Our fave ex-agents are back on the trail — this time chasing a missing Interpol Secretary General. Spoiler: it leads them straight to a high-security prison. Because of course it does.

⚖️ Hulu | Reasonable Doubt | Season 3 Premiere

Jax is back in the courtroom grind, and drama follows like it owes her rent. An ex-child star + a crew of messy entourage = case of the week chaos.🎁 First two episodes are ready to stream.

💔 BET+ | Zatima | Two New Episodes

Just when Zac and Bryce try to celebrate, an unwanted guest crashes the party. Meanwhile, Lori is out here trying to save a marriage with duct tape and determination.

🕗 Primetime Punch (8:00 PM ET)

Ready to grab snacks and yell at your screen? Here’s your evening game plan:

🧠 CBS | Big Brother | DOUBLE EVICTION SPECIAL

It’s a two-hour super episode, and two unlucky houseguests are getting booted faster than you can say “expect the unexpected.” Drama will be served hot.

👨‍👩‍👧‍👦 ABC | Celebrity Family Feud

Comedians George Wallace vs. Lil Rel Howery, and celebrity chefs Bobby Flay vs. Carla Hall. Expect jokes, burns, and someone screaming “GOOD ANSWER!” at a terrible guess.

🍊 Bravo | Real Housewives of Orange County

Tamra tries to save the Temecula trip (lol), but a wild night in West Hollywood ends in major gossip bombs. Spoiler: someone talks trash, and someone cries.

🏈 Prime Video | Thursday Night Football

It’s Dolphins vs. Bills at Highmark Stadium. Expect touchdowns, tackles, and at least one ridiculous referee call we’ll all be mad about.

🕘 Plot Twists & Shockers (9:00 PM ET)

⚖️ HBO | The Case Against Adnan Syed

The docuseries returns with new revelations. If you thought this case was closed, think again — because the plot just thickened again.

⚽ FXX | Necaxa | Season 1 Finale

Just when the team is finding its rhythm, Coach Larcamón drops a bombshell. Perfectly on-brand for finales that like to rip your heart out.

🦅 HBO Max | Peacemaker

Peacemaker has choices to make, people to punch, and birds to rescue. Eagly’s MIA, Flag’s furious, and the 11th Street Kids are on the verge of imploding.This episode? Absolute chaos.

💋 Bravo | Real Housewives of Miami

Jody wants Lisa to put a ring on it (literally), and Adriana’s birthday turns dramatic when the identity of the cake-saboteur is revealed. Who ruins a cake, seriously?

🕙 Late-Night Lookers (10:00 PM ET)

🧵 Freeform | Project Runway

Designers are sent somewhere over the rainbow — it's an Oz-themed challenge. But it’s not all glitter and glam. Backstage drama is hitting the seams.

🎬 ABC | Robert Redford: The Life and Legacy

A touching special from 20/20 celebrating the iconic career of Robert Redford, who passed this week. Bring tissues — and your admiration for true Hollywood legends.

✅ TL;DR — What to Watch Tonight?

Binge It Before Work: Black Rabbit (Netflix)

Reality TV Lovers: Big Brother (CBS), RHOC (Bravo), RHOM (Bravo)

True Crime Watchers: The Case Against Adnan Syed (HBO)

Sports Fans: Thursday Night Football (Prime Video)

Feel-Good Nostalgia: Robert Redford Special (ABC)

That's your guide for today, TV fam! Same time tomorrow? Until then, stay comfy, stay opinionated, and as always — keep it locked on The TV Cave for your daily fix of what’s hot on the small screen.