top of page

The Gilded Age Season 4 Episode 3 Recap: Peggy Gets Her Fairytale Wedding, While Bertha Steals Agnes' Thunder

11 hours ago
8 min read
Happy bride and groom laugh in an ornate church, holding hands amid candles and flowers.

Spoiler Alert: This recap contains spoilers for The Gilded Age Season 4, Episode 3, "Ain't That Good News."


Leave it to The Gilded Age to give us a beautiful wedding, a mother-in-law from hell, a potential new romance, and a social showdown that nearly sends Agnes van Rhijn into orbit. Season 4, Episode 3, "Ain't That Good News," finally sees Peggy Scott walk down the aisle with Dr. William Kirkland, but getting to the altar comes with enough family drama to make anyone reconsider having a wedding in the first place.


Meanwhile, Bertha Russell has her eyes on a prize that technically belongs to Agnes, and George is doing his best to remind everyone that being rich doesn't automatically make you pleasant to live with. Between all the scheming, questionable romantic decisions, and one spectacular confrontation, this episode reminds us why watching wealthy people fight over dinner invitations is so entertaining.


Peggy and William Are Getting Married, But Elizabeth Has Other Plans

Peggy and William return to Newport ahead of their wedding, where William surprises his bride-to-be with a house. Yes, an entire house! While most people might appreciate being consulted before their future husband makes such an enormous purchase, William figures surprising Peggy with a vacation home is perfectly reasonable. His intentions are sweet, but Peggy is understandably caught off guard.


The house also represents another complication in their relationship. Peggy has worked hard to establish herself as an independent woman with professional ambitions, and marrying into the Kirkland family shouldn't mean giving up her voice. William might adore her, but he still has some learning to do when it comes to making decisions together.

Unfortunately, buying houses without discussing them is the least of Peggy's problems because Elizabeth Kirkland is back to remind everyone that she believes her opinion is the only one that matters. William's mother has practically appointed herself the director, producer, and executive in charge of this wedding, and she isn't interested in hearing suggestions from the actual bride.


Things become especially uncomfortable when Peggy's family introduces two meaningful traditions they want included in the ceremony. Peggy's cousin plans to bring the Fisk Jubilee Singers to perform, while Arthur and Dorothy Scott want the newlyweds to jump the broom, a tradition with deep significance to their family.


Elizabeth is horrified by both ideas, dismissing the singers and treating the broom-jumping ceremony as something beneath the Kirkland family's social standing. Her objections aren't simply about wedding preferences. They reveal how determined she is to distance herself from the history and traditions that Peggy's family holds dear. And let's be clear, Elizabeth may have money and social connections, but she could certainly use a lesson in manners.



Peggy Refuses to Let Her Mother-in-Law Ruin the Wedding

William isn't pleased with his mother's behavior, and tensions between the Kirklands and Scotts threaten to overshadow what should be a joyful occasion. Elizabeth seems unwilling to consider that Peggy's family deserves just as much representation in the ceremony as her own. Peggy, however, isn't about to let Elizabeth turn her wedding into another battle. Rather than abandon the traditions that matter to her parents, she works to find a way forward without allowing the disagreement to destroy William's relationship with his mother.


When the big day finally arrives, there's uncertainty over whether Elizabeth will even attend. Thankfully, she shows up, although nobody should mistake her presence for a sudden personality transformation. She still looks like someone who would rather be anywhere else.


But this is Peggy and William's moment, and what a beautiful moment it is. The Fisk Jubilee Singers perform, Peggy's family traditions are honored, and the newlyweds jump the broom after exchanging their vows. The ceremony is especially meaningful because Peggy doesn't have to erase any part of her family's history to become a Kirkland. Elizabeth can disapprove all she wants, but Peggy gets the wedding she deserves.


One particularly touching moment comes when Marian visits Peggy before the ceremony and gives her the train ticket Peggy purchased for her when they first met. It's a lovely callback to the beginning of their friendship and a reminder of how much these two women have experienced together. After everything Peggy has endured, seeing her surrounded by love and celebrating her marriage is a welcome change. Now, can we please allow her to enjoy being a newlywed before giving her another crisis?


George Russell Is Still His Own Worst Enemy

Back in New York, things remain complicated in the Russell household. George returned to Bertha at the end of the previous episode, suggesting that the estranged couple might finally be finding their way back to one another. Apparently, George didn't get the memo that reconciliation requires actually being nice to your spouse. His dependence on laudanum continues to affect his behavior, and the pressure surrounding his business dealings with John D. Rockefeller isn't helping matters. George knows the future of his company could depend on securing Rockefeller's cooperation, but he's becoming increasingly difficult to reason with.


When Bertha suggests inviting the Rockefellers to dinner, George rejects her offer instead of recognizing that his wife might actually be able to help. Considering Bertha's entire existence revolves around getting powerful people into her dining room, this seems like a particularly foolish decision. George's temper and unpredictable behavior are becoming serious concerns. Bertha has made plenty of mistakes in their marriage, but watching him push away someone who could help protect everything they've built is frustrating. Of course, Bertha isn't the kind of woman who sits around waiting for permission to make a move. If George won't accept her assistance, she'll simply find another way to make herself indispensable. And Agnes is about to pay the price.


Bertha Russell Pulls Off Another Social Power Move

Agnes has been preparing to host a presidential dinner for Grover Cleveland, an honor that means everything to a woman who considers herself one of New York society's most important gatekeepers. Unfortunately, Agnes made the mistake of agreeing to an interview with Ladies' Home Journal, and the resulting article is far from flattering. Instead of presenting her as a respected authority, the piece makes her seem hopelessly old-fashioned.


Naturally, Agnes is furious. She's convinced that hosting an impeccable dinner for the president will remind everyone exactly who they're dealing with. But while Agnes is busy planning her revenge, Bertha spots an opportunity. Bertha approaches the Heritage Society and argues that the Russell mansion would be a more suitable location for the presidential dinner. With its modern conveniences and grand accommodations, her home offers advantages that Agnes's residence simply can't match.


And because Bertha never does anything halfway, she even contacts the White House to help secure the arrangement.

By the time Agnes returns from Newport, the decision has been made. The presidential dinner is moving across the street to the Russell mansion, and Agnes learns that the honor she was looking forward to has effectively been hijacked. Oh, Bertha. You really do enjoy playing with fire.


Agnes Marches Across the Street, and All Hell Breaks Loose

If anyone thought Agnes would quietly accept losing her presidential dinner to Bertha Russell, they clearly haven't been paying attention for the last four seasons. After receiving the news, Agnes is absolutely livid. Bertha hasn't merely inconvenienced her. As far as Agnes is concerned, she's committed an unforgivable act of social warfare. And Agnes isn't about to send a polite note expressing her disappointment.


Instead, she marches directly across the street to confront her rival. The ensuing exchange is everything we could hope for from Christine Baranski and Carrie Coon, with Agnes demanding answers while Bertha remains infuriatingly composed.

Bertha insists that Agnes is technically still hosting the dinner, even though the event will take place inside the Russell mansion. Apparently, Bertha thinks this distinction should make Agnes feel better. Spoiler alert: It doesn't.


The situation becomes even more ridiculous when Agnes discovers that Bertha used her telephone to contact the White House. Agnes is now contending with a woman who not only has more money and a larger house but also knows how to use modern technology to get exactly what she wants. Ada eventually arrives to retrieve her furious sister, but the damage is already done. Bertha has won this round, and Agnes may need several days to recover from the indignity. George witnesses enough of the confrontation to understand what Bertha has accomplished. Suddenly, his wife's talent for navigating society doesn't seem quite so useless. He acknowledges that the presidential dinner could be critical to the family's survival, placing an enormous responsibility on Bertha's shoulders. So after dismissing her earlier offer to help, George is now counting on her to save the day? Sir, make up your mind.



Oscar and Enid Entertain New York's Younger Society

Elsewhere, Oscar and Enid are trying to establish themselves as the hosts of a fashionable new social circle, beginning with an artistic salon that attracts a younger crowd. Their gathering features painter William Merritt Chase and offers an alternative to the traditional events favored by New York's established society figures. Of course, you can't have a proper social event without someone getting into a little trouble.


Jack Trotter attends and finds himself attracting attention from Miss Summers, a young woman who appears genuinely interested in his accomplishments as an inventor. Jack is still getting accustomed to his newfound wealth and status, but that doesn't stop him from spending an astonishing $1,000 on a painting. Someone might want to remind Jack that impressing women doesn't necessarily require spending a small fortune on artwork.


The salon also introduces Lee Klein, a painter who quickly catches Oscar's attention. Their interaction carries a noticeable flirtatious energy, which could become a problem for Oscar's marriage. Enid might believe she's building the perfect fashionable life with her husband, but Oscar's attraction to men hasn't disappeared simply because he's married. His connection with Lee could complicate an arrangement that already comes with plenty of secrets. Oscar and Enid's attempt to reinvent society might be successful, but their personal lives could prove much harder to manage.


Is Romance Finally Coming for Ada?

The wedding also introduces a potential new love interest for Ada, and frankly, we're already rooting for her.

At the ceremony, Ada encounters Dr. Harris, a former professor of William's, after he helps her retrieve something she's dropped. Their interaction is brief, but the chemistry is noticeable. Ada has experienced tremendous loss, and it would be lovely to see her find companionship again. Dennis Haysbert's arrival as Dr. Harris certainly makes that possibility more intriguing. Of course, this is The Gilded Age, so we shouldn't assume anything will be simple. But after spending so much time supporting everyone else, Ada deserves a little happiness of her own. And if a handsome doctor happens to be part of that happiness, who are we to complain?


Final Thoughts: Peggy Wins Her Wedding, Bertha Wins the War

"Ain't That Good News" delivers two very different victories. Peggy gets to marry the man she loves without sacrificing the traditions that connect her to her family, while Bertha proves once again that she's perfectly capable of outmaneuvering New York's old guard.


Peggy's wedding is easily the emotional highlight of the episode. Denée Benton brings warmth and determination to a character who refuses to let her future mother-in-law dictate every aspect of her life. Elizabeth may not approve of everything Peggy represents, but she's going to have to accept that her son has married a woman who knows her own mind.


Meanwhile, Christine Baranski nearly steals the entire episode with Agnes's reaction to losing the presidential dinner. Her outrage is magnificent, and watching her storm into Bertha's house is exactly the kind of deliciously petty drama this series does best.


But beneath the humor, there's serious trouble brewing. George's addiction continues to threaten both his marriage and his business, Oscar appears headed toward another dangerous romantic entanglement, and Bertha has placed herself in the position of potentially saving the Russell family. The wedding bells have stopped ringing, but the battle for New York society is just getting started. And something tells us Agnes won't be forgiving Bertha anytime soon.


What did you think of Peggy and William's wedding? And whose side are you on in the latest Agnes versus Bertha showdown?


The Gilded Age airs Sundays at 9 p.m. ET on HBO and streams on HBO Max.


📺 Love TV as much as we do? Follow @thetvcave on social media for breaking news, exclusive interviews, spoilers, and more!


What did you think?

  • Loved it

  • Hated it

  • So/So


Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page