Doctor Who Season 2 Episode 3 “The Well” Review: A Chilling Dive into Psychological Sci-Fi

Looking for a deep dive into “Doctor Who” Season 2 Episode 3? "The Well" delivers a haunting balance of tension, moral ambiguity, and slow-burn science fiction. Let’s unpack it.

“Doctor Who” has never been coy about experimenting with storytelling and Doctor Who Season 2, Episode 3, titled “The Well,” proves that. This episode takes viewers on a moody, suspense-laden journey through 1952 Florida, adding a unique twist to the show’s long-standing tradition of alien encounters. This episode brings a fresh yet nostalgic flavor to the TARDIS table and proves why we love following this Time Lord through space. 

The episode takes place in a remote astronaut training facility in post-war Florida, “The Well” begins with the Doctor and new companion Belinda arriving amid trouble. A mysterious alien force has taken over the base, but instead of a traditional alien showdown, the episode takes a different turn and explores the emotional and psychological actions of the crew. The themes explored in this episode, isolation and distrust, much like Midnight (a fan-favorite), the threat here isn’t always what you see but what you feel. Also the fear of the unknown, the “well” becomes both a literal and symbolic metaphor for the depths of human fear. The moral choices under pressure as the crew, led by the commanding but morally torn Shaya (Caoilfhionn Dunne), faces tough decisions that test their humanity.

Where “The Well” really shines is in its performances. Rather than focusing on action-heavy sequences, this episode touches on intense dialogue and different character dynamics. Caoilfhionn Dunne as Shaya delivers a compelling portrayal of a leader cracking under the pressure of an unseen threat and of course Ncuti Gatwa’s Doctor balances charm with quiet intensity, offering moments of emotional intelligence rather than his usual bravado while Belinda (Millie Gibson) continues to grow into her role, offering fresh perspectives and vulnerability that complement the Doctor’s enigmatic presence.

“The Well” takes a slow, deliberate pace, choosing unease over spectacle. The alien itself isn’t fully explained, adding to the atmospheric dread and inviting viewers to interpret its meaning.

According to director Amanda Brotchie, the design of “The Well” was inspired by Cold War-era isolation experiments. From dimly lit corridors to prolonged silences and unsettling sound design, “The Well” excels in all aspects from lighting choices, camera angles and even the score.

Overall the emotional depth, innovative structure, and strong performances give the episode a high ranking. But there were some issues with the season overall with some slower pacing and lack of action in some parts as well as not fully explaining the aliens.

Still, the episode is the kind of installment that sticks with you, not for what it shows, but what it suggests. If you’re into character-driven, psychological sci-fi. “Doctor Who” Season 2 Episode 3 might not feature grand alien battles or massive plot twists, but it's great because of  the subtle horror and emotional storytelling.

It pushes the boundaries of what a Doctor Who episode can be quiet, eerie, and hauntingly beautiful.

Did the slow pace work for you, or were you craving more action? Let us know in the comments or tag us on social media with your thoughts. And if you’re catching up on Season 2, check out our reviews for Episodes 1 and 2 as well.

Don’t forget to share this article with fellow Whovians especially those who love a good psychological mystery.

What did you think?

Change Image

• Loved it
• Hated it
• So/So