Sheriff Country Pilot Review: Is the Fire Country Spinoff Already More Compelling Than Its Predecessor?

CBS may have stumbled upon its next small-town obsession with Sheriff Country, a spinoff that dares to ask, what if the sheriff had just as much baggage as the criminals she’s locking up? From the ashes (literally) of Fire Country rises a pilot that is far messier, far juicier procedural with emotional stakes, family dysfunction, and yes, Morena Baccarin in a badge. And if that alone isn’t enough to get you to watch, let’s just say Matt Lauria is giving the silver foxes a run for their money.

The series premiere wastes no time setting the tone. Baccarin plays Mickey Fox, Edgewater’s interim sheriff who steps into the role following the exit of the previous one in a corruption scandal. She’s tough, capable, emotionally guarded, and trying very hard not to implode under the weight of her personal life. Her teenage daughter is newly sober and now possibly a murder suspect. Her father is a charming ex-con. And her ex-husband is dating her protégé. Small town, big mess.

Sheriff Country knows what it wants to be out the gate. It embraces the mess and makes it the main attraction. The procedural case in the pilot, a child abuse investigation that spirals into a dangerous rescue, gives Baccarin plenty of room to flex both her authority and vulnerability. But it’s the simmering dynamics that steal the show.

The real tension is between Mickey and her newly frenemy deputy, Nathan Boone, played with intense, slow-burn energy by Matt Lauria. These two are coiled up tighter than a California wildfire line, and their push-pull power struggle is one of the most compelling threads of the pilot. There’s betrayal. There’s loyalty. There’s a hint of something more. In other words, it’s everything you want from a “cop show” that actually knows characters drive the story.

Then comes the soapy goodness. Christopher Gorham drops in as Mickey’s ex-husband, now cozy with her mentee Cassidy, played by Michele Weaver. It is gloriously awkward and borderline messy, which makes it appointment television. Throw in Mickey’s charmingly shady dad (Wes), and you’ve got enough family drama to make a therapist retire early.

To its credit, Sheriff Country doesn’t assume viewers have seen a single frame of Fire Country. It gives enough connective tissue to orient the newcomers without bogging down the pacing. That’s a smart move. The show wants to stand on its own two boots, and so far, it does.

The standout here is Morena Baccarin, who brings a grounded weariness to Mickey that makes her feel lived-in from the jump. She is not a shiny TV sheriff with all the answers. She is trying to keep her daughter out of jail, her father out of trouble, and her badge from being revoked by people who underestimate her. And that’s before breakfast.

Is Sheriff Country better than Fire Country? I'll leave that up to y'all that have actually seen more that two episodes. But for me, Fire Country is appears to know how to balance the procedural bones with character-driven story. The pilot is confident and juicy, setting up not just a mystery arc involving a murder but also an emotional powder keg between its leads. If CBS plays this right, it has a new fan-favorite on its hands.

Final Verdict: Sheriff Country isn’t just a worthy spinoff, it might be the show I was expecting Fire Country to be. No shade, the flagship show just isn't for me.

Rating: 8.5 out of 10 – Come for Morena, stay for the chaos.

What did you think of the Sheriff Country premiere? Sound off in the comments or tweet us your hottest Edgewater takes.

What did you think?

Change Image

• Loved it
• Hated it
• So/So