I Know What You Did Last Summer 2025 Review: Nostalgia, Screams, and Slight Regrets

The Slasher is Back and He’s Wearing a Hoodie Now

They say everything old becomes new again, especially in Hollywood. If you thought the Fisherman had finally hung up his hook, I Know What You Did Last Summer 2025 is here to remind you that secrets never die, and neither do 90s horror franchises. But does this latest reboot bring the thunder or is it just another soulless cash grab dredged up from the bottom of the nostalgia barrel?

In this spoiler-free I Know What You Did Last Summer 2025 review, we’re diving deep into the blood-soaked waters of the I Know What You Did Last Summer 2025 remake. We’ll look at what works, what totally doesn’t, and whether this reboot is worth your time or just another reason to revisit the original. Expect returning legends, fresh meat, and plenty of jump scares that may or may not make sense.

The Premise: New Faces, Old Secrets, Familiar Hooks

At its core, the story is the same. A group of hot twenty-somethings (because no one actually hires real teenagers) makes a horrible decision one summer night and swears to never speak of it again. Fast forward a year, and someone with a thirst for revenge and a penchant for waterproof jackets starts picking them off one by one.

This time, the cast is led by Chase Sui Wonders, who plays Ava, a guilt-ridden college student trying to keep her life and secrets together. She’s joined by an ensemble of influencers, athletes, and at least one TikTok star trying to act like they’ve seen real trauma. But the real kicker? Jennifer Love Hewitt and Freddie Prinze Jr. are back as Julie and Ray, stepping in as legacy characters who apparently never learned their lesson.

Acting and Characters: Not All Millennials Are Built the Same

One of the film’s biggest strengths is its cast. Chase Sui Wonders brings a surprising amount of depth and believability to her role, even if the script occasionally forgets to let her do more than scream or sulk. Madelyn Cline and Brandon Flynn also add flavor as the spoiled rich girl and the jock with a soft side. Think Riverdale meets Scream Queens with a splash of brooding Gen Z anxiety.

The legacy characters? Well, they’re here. Jennifer Love Hewitt still has that wide-eyed look of perpetual dread, and Freddie Prinze Jr. is clearly just happy to be invited. Their inclusion mostly works, though some fans will feel they were more cameo than character.

Direction and Tone: Trying to Be Scary and Self-Aware, Failing at Both

Director Jennifer Kaytin Robinson brings an Instagram-filtered aesthetic to the horror genre. The movie is slick, fast-paced, and almost aggressively aware that it is a reboot. There are nods to the original everywhere, from the iconic “What are you waiting for” moment to the good old-fashioned hook weapon.

But the tone? It is all over the place. One minute it wants to be a serious psychological thriller, the next it is cracking jokes like it is in a parody. This identity crisis leads to jarring shifts that leave you unsure whether to laugh, scream, or roll your eyes. And the scares? You’ve seen scarier things on your bank statement.

Kills and Gore: Creative But Predictable

Let’s face it, in a slasher movie, we show up for the kills. And in this department, the remake delivers… kind of. The murder scenes are creative enough to get a reaction, with just the right amount of blood to keep it from feeling like a PG-13 snoozefest. But here’s the issue: once the formula becomes obvious, the suspense drains faster than the cast’s blood.

Also, can we stop with the jump scare fake-outs? There are only so many times a cat can leap out of a closet before it stops being scary and starts being a meme.

Final Twist: Plot Holes and a Groan-Worthy Reveal

Without giving too much away, let’s just say the final act wants to shock you but ends up confusing more than anything. The twist is telegraphed so early that even the least genre-savvy viewer will see it coming a mile away. And the big confrontation? It involves a lot of yelling, some conveniently timed flashbacks, and a character doing something so illogical you’ll wonder if they hit their head before filming.

The Verdict: Is It Worth Watching

So here’s the deal. If you’re a die-hard fan of the original and love revisiting old stories with a fresh coat of blood, then I Know What You Did Last Summer 2025 might be your guilty pleasure. It is not groundbreaking. It is not clever. But it is entertaining in that “I’ll watch this with a group of friends and make fun of it” kind of way.

However, if you’re looking for a slasher that truly reinvents the genre or offers intelligent storytelling, you might want to skip this one and rewatch Scream instead.

The Fisherman Lives, But Should He Have Stayed Dead

The I Know What You Did Last Summer 2025 remake is a glossy, mildly fun, and ultimately forgettable entry into the world of horror reboots. It checks the boxes, delivers a few chills, and gives longtime fans something to tweet about. But it never quite figures out what it wants to be, leaving viewers caught somewhere between nostalgia and frustration.

Still, if you love slasher flicks and have 90 minutes to burn, go ahead and dive in. Just don’t expect to be blown away. And whatever you do… don’t hit play without locking your doors.

Also, poor one out for Nicholas Alexander Chavez and Lola Tung whose scenes were cut. I would be interested to see the deleted scenes.

Did you watch the remake yet? Think it’s a guilty pleasure or a crime against horror? Drop your thoughts in the comments below and let’s scream about it.

What did you think?

Change Image

• Loved it
• Hated it
• So/So