A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms Season 1 Episode 1 Review: Game of Thrones Goes Sitcom?
- Je-Ree
- 3 minutes ago
- 3 min read
The Game of Thrones universe expands once again with the premiere of HBO’s A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms and for longtime fans, it’s an adventure that is…unexpectedly lighthearted. Set roughly 100 years after House of the Dragon and a century before the events of Game of Thrones, the series follows the adventures of Ser Duncan the Tall (Dunk) and his young squire Egg, who eventually
SPOILER ALERT
becomes Aegon V Targaryen. For those familiar with George R.R. Martin’s Tales of Dunk and Egg, it’s a story steeped in the lore of Westeros, but for fans coming in fresh or like me, avid watchers of the main series and House of the Dragon but book virgins, the first episode takes you by surprise.
From the opening moments, it’s clear that HBO is aiming for something drastically different from its predecessors. Gone are the ruthless political machinations, blood-soaked betrayal and looming dragon fire. In their place, viewers are treated to a sitcom-style Game of Thrones complete with humor, whimsical scenarios and a much lighter tone. Dunk (Peter Claffey), tall, handsome and earnest, is a classic sweetheart hero, while Egg, portrayed by a delightfully charming young actor named Dexter Sol Ansell, injects adorable energy into the dynamic duo. The acting is solid but the show’s playful, almost comedic approach to Westeros might leave die-hard fans craving the gritty, dangerous tension that defined the original series.
The first episode introduces Dunk and Egg as they navigate a world full of knights, jousts and political minor squabbles but without the sense of peril or looming stakes that made fans fall in love with Game of Thrones. While I appreciate the craftsmanship, the humor-heavy scenes, ranging from awkward social encounters to awkward bodily function jokes feel oddly out of place in the world I’ve come to associate with intrigue and moral ambiguity. It’s a Westeros without the edge and for some, that’s refreshing; for me, it’s a bit jarring.
That said, the show does succeed in giving viewers an accessible entry point into the Dunk and Egg storylines, especially for those who haven’t read the books. The narrative is clear, the pacing brisk and the chemistry between Dunk and Egg is charming enough to make you root for their journey, even if you find yourself longing for darker plot twists. The medieval settings are beautifully rendered and the production values feel right at home on HBO. The absence of dragons is notable but doesn’t detract from the story, it simply signals a shift toward smaller, character-driven adventures rather than sweeping fantasy epics.
Despite its strengths, the premiere may not satisfy fans like me who crave the ruthless, tension-filled storytelling that made the Game of Thrones universe addictive. The humor and lighthearted tone, while appealing to some, dilute the sense of danger and consequence. It’s charming, yes but I found myself missing the thrill of backstabbing, political maneuvering and the very real stakes that once had me glued to the screen.
A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms Episode 1 is a mixed bag: a visually appealing, well-acted and surprisingly cute Westeros adventure that leans more toward comedy than drama. Dunk and Egg are endearing leads and the show has potential to carve its own niche within the sprawling Game of Thrones universe. However, for fans seeking the ruthless intrigue, high-stakes drama and dark fantasy that defined the original series, this sitcom-style take may feel a little too playful. HBO has taken a gamble with tone and while some viewers will love the charm and warmth, others, myself included, may find it hard to embrace the lighter side of Westeros just yet.
For those curious about how this spin-off fits into the broader Game of Thrones timeline and eager to see a different slice of the world, Episode 1 delivers an approachable, if unconventional, introduction. Just don’t expect dragons, treachery or the kind of perilous thrills that made Westeros famous.
What did you think?
Loved it
Hated it
So/So