Tell Me Lies Season 3 Episode 4 “Fix Me Up, Girl” Review: Messy Confessions, Weaponized Secrets and the Art of Emotional Sabotage
- Je-Ree
- 1 day ago
- 3 min read
If Tell Me Lies has taught us anything over the years, it’s that no one on this show ever says what they mean and when they finally do, it’s usually too late. Season 3, Episode 4, “Fix Me Up, Girl,” leans hard into that tradition, delivering one of the season’s messiest, most psychologically bruising hours yet. This is Tell Me Lies at its most unhinged: secrets spreading faster than common sense, relationships rotting in real time and Stephen DeMarco once again proving he’s the human embodiment of a red flag emoji parade.
From the jump, the episode makes it clear this is a turning-point chapter. The emotional stakes are higher, the lies sharper, and the fallout more unavoidable. The show continues its dual-timeline structure, cutting between the characters’ college years and the wedding-day future that hangs over everything like a storm cloud waiting to burst.
Stephen Stays Awful, Diana Stands Her Ground
At the center of “Fix Me Up, Girl” is Diana’s pregnancy storyline, which finally explodes into the open. What begins as a deeply personal decision quickly becomes public knowledge thanks to loose lips and misplaced loyalty, an ongoing theme this season. Stephen’s reaction is exactly what longtime viewers expect: controlling, manipulative and wrapped in the language of concern.
Rather than offering support, Stephen attempts to assert ownership over Diana’s choices, pushing for involvement and validation he hasn’t earned. The episode’s strongest moments come when Diana refuses to play along. Her confrontation with Stephen is sharp, restrained, and emotionally devastating, highlighting just how far she’s come compared to the people still orbiting his chaos. It’s a rare moment of clarity in a show that thrives on emotional fog.
Wedding Bells and Emotional Landmines
The future-timeline scenes at Bree and Evan’s wedding continue to drip with tension and Episode 4 adds another layer by circling back to the mystery of Bree’s unsettling phone calls. The answers don’t arrive with fireworks, but with quiet dread. When Stephen pieces together the truth, the episode closes in on him like a shark catching a scent in the water.
The brilliance here is restraint. Rather than blowing up the wedding outright, the episode lets the knowledge simmer.
Stephen doesn’t need to act immediately; the threat of what he might do is far more effective. It’s classic Tell Me Lies: cruelty as a slow burn.
Lucy’s Self-Destructive Spiral Continues
Lucy’s arc remains difficult to watch in the most intentional way possible. Still untangling her identity from past trauma, she drifts into another emotionally hollow connection, one that feels less like chemistry and more like punishment. The episode doesn’t glamorize her choices, and that’s the point. Lucy isn’t regressing because she’s weak; she’s regressing because she’s human, damaged and painfully aware of it.
“Fix Me Up, Girl” underscores how deeply Stephen’s influence lingers, even when he’s not in the room. Lucy may be physically distant from him, but the patterns he helped carve are stubborn and familiar.
A Series at Full Confidence
What makes Tell Me Lies Season 3 Episode 4 work so well is its confidence. The show no longer rushes emotional beats or overexplains motivations. It trusts the audience to sit with discomfort, to recognize manipulation when it appears, and to understand that growth isn’t linear especially when everyone involved is still lying, just in more sophisticated ways.
The writing remains sharp, the performances grounded and the tone perfectly calibrated between grim realism and darkly watchable chaos. “Fix Me Up, Girl” doesn’t resolve much, but it rearranges the board in ways that make the next moves inevitable and likely devastating.
As the season barrels forward, this episode stands out as a quiet storm: no massive explosions, just pressure building in every corner. If Tell Me Lies is about the long-term consequences of emotional dishonesty, Episode 4 makes one thing painfully clear no one gets out clean, and the mess is only getting started.
What did you think of “Fix Me Up, Girl”? Let the spiraling commence.
What did you think?
Loved it
Hated it
So/So
Comments